THE EDITOR:
THE People’s Business, which aired on July 30, 2006
on Bajan TV, attempted to analyse the ongoing CJ imbroglio unfolding
in TnT.
In a classic manifestation of “fools rush in where angels
fear to tread” it was both entertaining and informative.
The input via telephone of Bajan commentator Julian Rogers spared
the young Indian Trini expert, from threatened ambush by a determined
Professor McIntosh.
Rogers’ reasoned and fair provision of pertinent facts, both
obvious and unstated, were refreshing.
They effectively discredit-ed the good professor’s hide bound
and tunnel vision.
The latter’s aggressive commitment to the false premise that
the CJ is entitled to no legal protect-ion against police humilia-tion
and manhandling, clearly instigated to serve a political agenda,
is sweet music to any dictatorship in the making.
As already posited in the TnT media, were McIntosh’s offended
sensibilities, so obviously slanted against the CJ, when the spirit
of both constitutional propriety and democratic dictate were Presidentially
trampled on December 24, 2001?
The guest expert from TnT spared the necessity of rebutting McIntosh’s
misleading construct on a constitutional issue demanding the keenest
interest throughout the region.
While McIntosh is constitutionally entitled to public expression
of personal interpretation, even on issues upon which he is so clearly
ill informed, his vehemence is a source of serious concern; as was
his arrogant dismissal of the Honourable Justice Judith Jones as
a “junior judge”, insulting.
If as posited, the good professor was mentor of TnT’s own
sadly misdirected AG Jeremie when he studied law at Cave Hill in
Barbados, then any further contemplation, expenditure or discussion
on the CCJ needs to be preceded by the im-mediate termination of
the study of law at any UWI campus.
If the two afore-named are exemplars of UWI’s best, the Caribbean
can only benefit from the added expense of educating young lawyers
in the homeland of the Privy Council, before which the issue in
question is destined for final resolution.
Clearly, based on McIntosh and Jeremie, in this discipline, UWI
has failed the Caribbean miserably!
Unless of course, Professor McIntosh’s contribution was a
subtle, pre-emptive, if not necessarily reasoned strike, motivated
solely by concern at the ongoing Indo proliferation in his own Barbados!
|