tntnews.net
Go Back Send us your Feedback Browse our Archives Friday Mirror Headlines
  Sunday Mirror Headlines

 

Ramsaran: ICC must investigate Lara’s dismissals
- as trigger-finger umpire keeps world record holder under the gun Down Under

FORMER Sports Minister Manohar Ramsaran is calling on the International Cricket Council (ICC) to investigate the current spate of questionable umpiring decisions that are getting in the way of Brian Lara beating an Australian’s batting record in Australia.

Lara started the three-Test series “Down Under” needing just 317 runs to surpass former Aussie captain Allan Border as the overall highest run-scorer in Test cricket history.

However, he has been out to dubious decisions three times in four innings so far.

Ramsaran, who was this country’s Sports Minister between 1995 and 2001, felt it was too much of a coincidence to remain quiet on the issue, especially since match fixing is no stranger to “the Gentleman’s Game”.

“I wish to call publicly for a thorough investigation into the reason Brian Lara is subjected to so many wrong decisions, I daresay cheated,” Ramsaran told TnT Mirror.

RUDI KOERTZEN

RUDI KOERTZEN

MANOHAR RAMSARAN

MANOHAR
RAMSARAN


“How come in four innings, the world’s Number 1 is given out twice, two instances clearly not out and another where the benefit (of the doubt) should be in his favour?

“ICC, please, with all the technology available, your slip is showing,” he charged.

On Saturday, while attempting to save West Indies from a second successive defeat, Lara fended at a wide ball from Shane Warne that was caught by wicketkeeper Adam Gilchrist.

The Australians appealed aggressively and umpire Rudi Koertzen raised his finger, but slow-motion replays could not establish that the ball touched the edge of Lara’s bat.

Television footage from Channel Nine showed that the sound picked up by a “snickometre” might have been that of the bat flicking the pad.

This, like the leg-before wicket decision that went against him in the first innings, was not the kind of howler he got in the first innings of the Brisbane Test, but it was enough to reinforce the impression that the world’s greatest batsmen, such as Lara and Sachin Tendulkar of India, tend to receive the rough end of contentious decisions.

Nine’s Hawkeye technology also suggested that the full delivery by Brett Lee that hit Lara’s pad would have clipped leg stump (which is not LBW).

BRIAN LARA

Frustration is etched on WI star batsman
BRIAN LARA’s face as he is contentiously
given out by umpire RUDI KOERTZEN,
caught behind in the second innings
of the second Test against Australia.

But in the first innings at the Gabba, it showed clearly that he had been wronged on two counts -- Lara got a thick inside edge and the ball was missing leg.

West Indies officials were reluctant to comment on Lara’s luck with the umpires and can be heavily fined for criticising match officials.

Lara has so far scored 30, 14, 13 and 45 in the two Tests, in spite of which he has gone past another Aussie, Steve Waugh as the second highest aggregate run-getter in Test cricket.

He still needs 214 (if his scores in the Super Test are added; or 254, adding Tests for Windies only) to top the list ahead of Border and, with one Test to go, many feel it is a remote possibility of getting it in Australia, on current form and luck.

The matter did not escape former Windies pacer and renowned commentator Michael Holding who posed a half-serious trivia question to yet another Aussie captain Bill Lawry during Channel Nine’s commentary last week Sunday, asking how many times Lara would be given out fairly during the West Indies’ most miserable tour of Australia.

Holding declined to elaborate on his views but the answer to his question is probably once, when Lara was caught at gully by Matthew Hayden during the second innings in Brisbane.

Former Test all-rounder Bernard Julien also judged the dismissals unfair, saying he was uncertain “whether there is a conspiracy or something”.

He said it was unfair to Lara, who was already fighting for top form “while the team is not helping”.

Trinidad and Tobago Cricket Board official and coach Roland Sampath, when contacted by Mirror, did not comment on the decisions except to note that Lara usually walks once out but in these instances he has been standing around, staring or looking up in the air.

He also expressed the view that the burden of expectation was already too much and for too long on one man; therefore, the added pressure from Aussie fieldsmen and such umpiring decisions could amount to an insurmountable challenge for Lara for the balance of this series.

Another top local cricket official who prefers to speak off the record, could not comment on the decisions against Lara because: “I don’t wake up to see West Indies play anymore. I tend to grieve. I tend to hurt seeing them play.”

One irate cricket enthusiast Nasser Khan, promised to compile a DVD of all the dubious outs of Lara’s career so as to “embarrass the ICC and umpires into use of technology to override the ‘human errors’ that Brian Lara suffers from”.

Lara himself has remained mum on the issue but Ramsaran, a former captain of the Customs and Excise all-conquering cricket team as well as Division One Club Joe Public Munroe Road United, hopes to draw attention to the double world record-holder’s current predicament.

“I call on Lara to keep his chin up. Justice must be demanded and it will surely come,” he said, adding that Australia’s victories, given the circumstances, are hollow.
___________________________________________________________________________________
Archives | Feedback | Friday Mirror Home | Sunday Mirror Home | Go Back
© 2001 TnTNews.net